Debate: is Herobrine real? (LOCKED)
27 replies [Last post]
liquid_lightning
Epic Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 547233
WoM Coins: 1712

Okay, first thing first, I have designed this to be a game. So do not think that I am trying to throw everything into havoc. I just wanted to have a bit of 'forum fun' as it is the forum I am posting on. There may or may not be a panel of judges that will decide which side is more believable in this event. Until then, though, this is just a little debate. I will keep you posted as things change.

Rules:

1.You can pick a side on wether or not you believe in HIM (Herobrine In Minecraft).

2. You will then Debate about it in the comments.

3. Please do not constantly jump sides. If you want to change sides once or twice you can, but it is too confusing if you are constantly changing sides.

4.Have fun. Dont go freaking out all over this forum. that would ruin it for everyone.

5. You can post more than once. Yes, you do not need to pour all your feelings about HIM's existence into one comment. Just wait for at least one comment from another user before you add on your next edition.

 

You do not need to wholeheartedly believe in herobrine. Just have some fun and debate.

May the best side win!!!

Lunick
Officially Retired
Contributor +
WoM Member: 74757
WoM Coins: 8985

There is no siding in this. He simply does not exist.

Here, here, here, here, here and countless other evidence.

I'd love to see whatever proof you have...

awie1
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 224269
WoM Coins: 364
lol

no.

Usoka
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 83429
WoM Coins: 1973

There's no debate. He was never real.

Jupiter_Ginger
J.U.P.I.T.E.R
Community Managers
WoM Member: 295547
WoM Coins: 3343
(No subject)

liquid_lightning
Epic Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 547233
WoM Coins: 1712
you guys are forgetting

Alright, I know that nobody believes in herobrine. I am included. But it is A GAME! You do not nees to believe its true. Just to keep the game rolling, here is what I have to say. First of all, just saying he does not exist, is not very persuasive. Also, in the Minecraft wedding adventure picture, Herobrine can be seen in the right side of the picture. What do you have to say to that?

ssfdre38
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 369733
WoM Coins: 1405

its a joke that Notch put in a tweet and it has carried

liquid_lightning
Epic Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 547233
WoM Coins: 1712
Actually,

Well, What about all of the people who have seen herobrine? and, lunick, I am sorry to tell you this, but all of your sources are flawed. (No offense, btw) In the twitter posts, There are comments that dissagree with Notch's post, and on the Herobrine wiki page there is a portion that does say he is fake, but there is another portion that says he could be a virus because notch does not send emails saying stuff about a dead brother, yet there are, and he edits worlds. Basicly, he could be a virus, or a hacker. either or. but he is, according to that still real. Like I said. For arguments sake.

Usoka
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 83429
WoM Coins: 1973
Herobrine can only only be

Herobrine can only only be encounter in-game through the use of Mod, Texture Pack, and Skins. No way to find him in any other way.


Definatly no way to encounter him on a singleplayer, vanila world. Unless you're:
a) Hallucinating or,
b) Dreaming

In which case you only see what people tell you to see, not what he really is. Should there have ever been a real version of him.

Captain Goal
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 417577
WoM Coins: 2263
~

MissEmzystar
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 581125
WoM Coins: 11
What do I think?

Well, I think a few people made a texture packs with blocks that look like HIM or took screen shots then edited HIM in. So no I don't think he exsists but I think eventaly the makers of minecraft will realize it becomeing a thing so they will make him into a real mob.

see, anyone can fake him!

Decy
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 434365
WoM Coins: 1932
:o

It's not really a debate if there is proof it isn't real :D 

** Points at Lunicks proof **

carter2875
WoM Member
Members
WoM Member: 581150
WoM Coins: 1
Him is real

Him does exsist my friend found something in his house he didnt put there.

cartose777
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 456556
WoM Coins: 1826
What has this

What has this Minecraft world came to? Lies about Herobrine Man we need to get more proof oh IK     here's 1! Wow what big head he has :P         

 

 

EVA_Spartan_213
Senior Project Manager
Community Managers
WoM Member: 381334
WoM Coins: 5305
i haz the best video!

rockyracoon123
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 448881
WoM Coins: 729
lol

Nice vid

My debate HIM DOES NOT EXIST

Lunick
Officially Retired
Contributor +
WoM Member: 74757
WoM Coins: 8985

lunick, I am sorry to tell you this, but all of your sources are flawed.

Artbot
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 240770
WoM Coins: 1897
Herobrine is real just like

Herobrine is real just like dinosaurs are fake and the aliens abduct people by the teeth for their evil pencil  experiments.

 - That is all

 

cartose777
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 456556
WoM Coins: 1826
..

...Herobrine is real just like dinosaurs. That's when u lost me :P

FiXeroN
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 100275
WoM Coins: 398
...

niels
Staff Member
Community Managers
WoM Member: 1857
WoM Coins: 1714
Derp!

Quote:
lunick, I am sorry to tell you this, but all of your sources are flawed.

You just called a response from the original developers, a false statement

Well, I guess its time to go to

Gorakkhowk
Contributor
Contributor
WoM Member: 282019
WoM Coins: 496
Yes

I think he is real :D

Now before you get mad and argue against me, understand that I am not he IS real, I am just saying I THINK he's real.

cartose777
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 456556
WoM Coins: 1826
..

@niels: Lunick is not a maker of World of Minecraft but just a staff that helps people..He's pretty much not a maker of World of Minecraft.

Jupiter_Ginger
J.U.P.I.T.E.R
Community Managers
WoM Member: 295547
WoM Coins: 3343

There are really just two sides to this debate.

1. It was Aliens.

2. It was Aliens.

 

Now, i'm not trying to say that it was aliens. But, It was aliens.

AwsomeG2
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 281620
WoM Coins: 2369
§

He is not real, never was. There is proof that he was never in the game EVER so why do you bother still talking about this crap?

jak2131
Epic Contributor
Contributor +
WoM Member: 191805
WoM Coins: 6608
@cartose777

When niels said the developers, he meant the people who made minecraft, Lunick posted a load of links of the creators of minecraft saying that it is not real.

Lunick
Officially Retired
Contributor +
WoM Member: 74757
WoM Coins: 8985

Ok, I think this thread is a bad idea and it is now going to lock magically.